Mortar Idea

[bigbob12345]

think of pvc piston valves they undergo more force than this setup will ever generate. And they dont cack if you use pressure rated parts.

[Sergeant Dotson]

I have made 1 simple guide hole. And also the nail is not puncturing any PVC. I don't know where you got that idea from.


P.S.
I got up a new pic.

[OuchProgramme]

think of pvc piston valves they undergo more force than this setup will ever generate. And they dont cack if you use pressure rated parts.

Pistons under go PSI, not brute force. Here's a simple test....

Drop your airchamber while building your next gun.
Now pressurize it. Are you as confident w/ it as before?

Probably not. There's a weak spot where you dropped it, and when your pressurize the air chamber, it may just blow out on that spot.

Sergant: Sorry if my message came out weird. But when your pin strikes the end of the guide rail, it's going to smash into the pvc. After a couple of strikes, it's going to wear out and crack.

[bigbob12345]

What I mean is when the piston slams back.
Any piston of reasonable weight will exsert more force than this spring when it slams back.

[OuchProgramme]

What I mean is when the piston slams back.
Any piston of reasonable weight will exsert more force than this spring when it slams back.

Yes, but the piston force has a greater surface area to reduce damage at one spot. Much energy is put through one single pin in a guide rod, less surface area, many more pounds per sq inch.

Which one will be more effective?

A nail w/ 1,000 lbs/sq inch going through a plank of wood

Or a pvc piston w/ 1,000 lbs/sq inch going through the same plank of wood...

[bigbob12345]

Hmm I see your point.
We will have to wait and see what happens when he trys it Im sticking with my original opinion.

[OuchProgramme]

I'm glad you see it
I'm not trying to change the way he builds, but just argueing for a point.

[bigbob12345]

I do see your point but i still dont think it will be enough force to crack the pvc.
Any way if it cracks it will get replaced if it doesnt it will probably get replaced anyway so you get your way no matter what.

[Sergeant Dotson]

Well, I'm glad you two kids settled this argument. :hello1: Just kidding.

:laughing3:

[bigbob12345]

Ha, you just made me laugh pretty hard

[Jared Haehnel]

I'm pretty sure this is what you were talking about... but if it wasn't Ill put it out there any way.

If you use the piston to puncture the C02 canister. You drop the C02 down the tube and the piston propelled by a spring comes up and hits the back of the canister puncturing the seal. If the C02 is centered in the barrel and the piston's pin is centered you will get a consistent punch every time.


Its an idea and with out drawing it on paper I couldn't tell you how it would all work. But it would probably give you more constant results

[bigbob12345]

I just saw the new pic it is much clearer.
Well I am still going to say it all looks good I dont see anything wrong with it. Have you pulled the spring back and released it yet just to see if works?