piston-vs-sprinkler

[roughboy]

If you have 2 guns, one is a piston valve (Barrel sealling gun), and the other is a sprinkler valve/w blowgun (modded), both with the same size air chamber and same size barrel and with the same bullet and size of it.
Which is gonna be the loudest/powerfulest/and strongest???

THANKs Y'ALL!!!!!!

[A-98]

to put it nicely. the piston valve will kick the shit out of the sprinkler valve.

[jackssmirkingrevenge]

Which is gonna be the loudest/powerfulest/and strongest???

The piston will win hands down, it will dump more air faster and therefore accelerate the projectile quicker, meaning it will be stronger and "powerfuler" - and also, air will exit the muzzle at higher pressure therefore the report would be louder.

[hi]

here is a nice power comparison for you.

piston-



sprinkler-



I.E.- piston wins big time.

[Kenny_McCormic]

lol thats a grat comparison

[A-98]

nicely put. very subtle.

[mark.f]

I believe it was said that the flow from a sprinkler valve was equivalent to the flow of that from a 9/16" hole. With a piston valve, the flow is much higher. Maybe equivalent to the flow of up to a 1-1/2" hole. 8)

[noname]

This is an easy decision, just use both- the sprinkler valve to pilot a piston of the same size!

[Velocity]

I think that sprinkler valves are able to open up much faster than piston valves, because they have a lightweight diaphragm which only needs to flex instead of a heavier piston which needs to slide backward. However, the flow of a sprinkler valve is much less than the flow of a piston valve of similar size. I think that for a 1/2" barrel and lower, a sprinkler valve will be able to beat a piston valve. However, anything higher than that, and the piston will win easily.