@PVC Arsenal:
Thanks for the link. I'm liking those tanks and they're making me reconsider the aluminum cylinder I was looking at.
The cylinder I'm going for weighs about half a pound. That's 3.5 pounds taken off, which is very substantial.
Weight's not mission critical, but it's something I want to reduce.
I'm more interested in Nerf than paintball at the moment. I shouldn't have mentioned paintball because in my experience you need a high capacity tank unless you're playing stock class.
In most Nerf wars, most people are using either spring guns, which are cocked every shot, or pump guns, which need to be pumped every shot. If I can get 20 shots off without recharging, I'm at a huge advantage already. And given that barely anyone (I'm probably one of less than 10) people in Nerf even have HPA or CO2 tanks, the weight of the guns can make a difference.
Oddly, this is coming from a guy who's done a lot of stuff with water guns and those guns can easily weigh 20 pounds. It's all relative I suppose, and I find this point mildly amusing.
In a Nerf setting I think weight and being able to refill during the game is important, at least for the moment. Maybe I'll hate the lack of capacity once I get the tank.
@TurboSuper:
12 inches of 3 inch pipe has a capacity of 85 cubic inches, the same as the aluminum tank I'm interested in.
Here's the breakdown of the weight:
Pipe: 1.41 pounds (linear density from
here)
Caps: 2*0.464 pounds = 0.928 pounds (weight from
here)
Total weight: 2.34 pounds
A 125 cubic inch tank as you described would weigh about 3 pounds with the same weights and densities.
The aluminum tank I'm interested in weighs about 0.5 pounds for comparison. Given the differences in capacity and the difference in weight between HPA and PVC, I'd rather use the HPA tank. But given a similar capacity but very low weight aluminum tank I'd take the aluminum tank.